“It’s so good! You get to follow along with your favorite romcoms as they get turned inside-out. And if you haven’t watched the particular romcom it doesn’t really matter because the host does a great synopsis in the beginning, and the storyline gets warped anyway so it’s just a great listen no matter what. It’s so much fun. Love is Scary!”
— ViaVessel

“What a cool, creative concept. I recommend that anyone (even people who don't love horror) should listen to this truly unique podcast. It's both funny and insightful!”
— Matt Young (Hello From The Magic Tavern)

“This podcast is one of my favorites! As someone who is fond of lovingly mocking romcoms, But Make It Scary always hits the spot. Sequoia is a fun host with creative and hilarious ideas for spooky twists and her guests bring even more comedic horror plots to the table.”
- yoilovefanfic

“Really loved this podcast!! So funny, clever, and made me laugh like a maniac in public! Can’t wait for more episodes!”
— CaitiClarke

“This is a VERY GOOD pod and I don’t even really like scary movies!! I hesitated listening because I’m not usually a fan. Sequoia is the best host and I can’t wait to see what other ideas you come up with!”
- Amanda

“All the guests are funny and good creators and Sequoia is delightful! Even when I don’t know the original romcom, the new scary versions are 10/10.”
- overduefan